The Island Now

Conservative Party faces extinction in NY

Font Size:
Default font size
Larger font size

Posted: Thursday, March 14, 2013 2:57 pm

The New York State Conservative Party just celebrated its 51st Anniversary at its annual Conservative Party Political Action Committee Conference. 

Was there really reason to celebrate? 

One way of judging the health of any political party is looking at the number of candidates running for public office that qualify for ballot status on their line. 

Political parties are organized on a state Assembly basis with a male and female state committee person. 

Within each Assembly district are a series of election districts represented by two district committee people. Real political parties find candidates and enough active registered party members to circulate nominating petitions. 

You only need a handful of registered Conservative Party members within any Assembly district to qualify for ballot status as a candidate for the Assembly. The average Conservative Party enrollment per Assembly district averages in the hundreds. 

Finding this should be easy. This is necessary to acquire sufficient signatures for qualifying candidate ballot status. Those political parties that can’t perform this most basic task exist only on paper and are essentially dead. 

Up until the 1990s, Conservative Party members routinely qualified candidates for all Congressional, state Senate, state Assembly and New York City Council seats. 

This is not the case today, especially in New York City.

In 2012, the Conservative Party statewide was unable to field candidates on the ballot for five of 26 Congressional, 12 out of 63 Senate and 51 out of 150 State Assembly contests.

In the 2013 New York City Mayoral race, former Richmond County Conservative Party Chairman and current Staten Island Borough President Jim Molinaro recently endorsed Democratic New York City Council Speaker Christine Quinn. Molinaro has in the past been cross-endorsed by the Republican Party for Borough President. 

Quinn has a consistent liberal voting record on legislation and supporting Democrats. 

The Conservative Party platform is usually opposed to both the legislation and the candidates supported by Quinn. Staten Island historically has provided the margin of victory for past successful GOP mayoral candidates Rudy Guiliani and Michael Bloomberg. This is a sad commentary on the current state of the Conservative Party.

This decline followed the death of author and well known Conservative Party founder William F. Buckley in 2008. This parallels the Conservative Party entering the twilight of its own existence. 

Many are coming to the conclusion that some minor parties, such as the Conservatives, are yesterday’s news. 

The future demise of the Conservative Party can be traced to the profound impact of former Governor George “Taxpaki” Pataki. 

Ironically, Pataki was their keynote speaker at the recent convention. 

This group was founded in 1962 to provide a philosophical conservative alternative to the liberal Republican Party then dominated by the late Gov. Rockefeller, U.S. Sen. Javits, State Attorney General Lefkowitz and New York City Mayor Lindsay. 

Building upon Barry Goldwater’s 1964 defeat, they ran Buckley for New York City Mayor in 1965. 

His wit, wisdom and well defined philosophical conservative positions gave them both credibility and 13.5 percent of the vote. 

In 1966, building upon both the Goldwater and Buckley campaigns, they ran Adams for governor - they captured Row C from the Liberal Party in the 1966 election. 

They reached their peak in 1970 when they elected James Buckley to the U.S. Senate with just Conservative Party endorsement. 

They continued to play a critical role in electing D’Amato to the Senate in 1980, 1986 and 1992, along with President Reagan in 1980 and 1984 as well as President Bush in 1992.

With the election of Pataki as governor in 1994, they morphed into a Republican Party subsidiary. 

Political patronage became more important than philosophical principles. Numerous Conservative Party leaders, activists and family members shared in Pataki’s victory. They became beholden to the governor by accepting employment in the executive branch, agencies and quasi independent authorities controlled by Pataki. 

Former Pataki’s fiscal policies of huge yearly multibillion dollar budget increases which were significantly above the rate of inflation and accompanying multibillion-dollar yearly record growth in debt would have made former Conservative Party adversary Gov. Rockefeller roll over in his grave! 

Others went to work for GOP Assembly and Senators who received Conservative party cross endorsements. 

They are now part of the permanent Albany establishment which their ancestors fought decades earlier. Not biting the hand that feeds them, they ignored his liberal tax and spend financial mismanagement and endorsed Gov. Pataki for two additional terms in 1998 and 2002.

Their 1960s leadership would have not have endorsed, but run a candidate against Gov. Pataki who would have been much closer to their limited government free enterprise positions of old. 

The Liberal party following the same path of patronage over ideology eventually becoming irrelevant. They lost ballot status and were replaced by the Workers Family Party. While the Conservative Party leadership worshiped at the altar of Pataki/Bruno GOP Political Patronage, today they receive crumbs from Senate Republican leader Dean Skelos and GOP Assembly Minority Leader Brian Kolb. Libertarian, Green, Working Families and Independence parties stand for divergent philosophical principles. 

In 1998, the Independence Party received more votes for governor claiming Row C and dropping the Conservatives to Row D for the first time in 30 years. It took them 12 years to reclaim Row “C”.

From their successful times in the 1960s, the Conservative Party has morphed into the Conservative Political Patronage Party, losing their vim and vigor. They have been unable to assist Republicans from losing eight state Senate seats reducing them to a fragile one seat majority. The same is true for the loss of numerous former GOP Congressional and Assembly seats. There are few elected officials who win outright or whose margin of victory was a result of votes captured on the Conservative Party line. 

The late Bill Buckley’s past contributions as a candidate, author, newspaper columnist and publisher of National Review helped build the Conservative Party during its formative years decades ago. He would not be happy with what they have become.

Their impact is diminishing on the state landscape as they are entering the twilight of political history. Their leadership and enrollment base continues to both age and decline. Fewer new and younger voters are registering Conservative. 

Those who believe in limited government, free enterprise along with economic and civil liberties continue to look for other alternatives. 

In 2010, many voted for Kristin Davis (Anti-Prohibition), Warren Redich (Libertarian), Steve Cohen (TEA) or Carl Palidino (Taxpayers) party candidates for Governor rather than Row C.

It is possible that their candidate for governor in 2014 may be unable to attract the minimum 50,000 votes necessary to maintain permanent ballot status.


Larry Penner

Great Neck

More about

More about

More about

Welcome to the discussion.